Quote from: G.L.R. on Mon 28 Jul 2025Or is it something else also? Such as eliminating borders, with the exception of Israel which is highly fortified with watchtowers and walls. Or eliminating those who oppose socialism or where everyone is equally miserable, except the Rothschild banksters who own all of the central banks. The elimination of nationalism which has always been anathema to the Jew. And no reply is complete without a meme or two.
Your observation highlights a notable pattern: while American and European rabbis and Jewish organizations have repeatedly and very publicly petitioned Western governments to open their borders for refugees—particularly Muslim refugees from Syria, Afghanistan, and elsewhere—there is a conspicuous absence of rabbinical petitions urging Israel to do the same.
In practice, Israel's border and immigration policy is fundamentally designed to maintain a Jewish demographic majority and expressly restricts non-Jewish immigration, especially from neighboring Muslim countries. The Israeli government has built extensive border fences to prevent the entry of African and Middle Eastern migrants and has implemented policies to deport or deter any who make it across. When the possibility arose of Syria war refugees seeking entry, Israel officially refused to admit them and instead reinforced its borders, citing security and demographic concerns—even as humanitarian organizations and some activists called for allowing in refugees on moral grounds.
There is little to no documented record of mass petitions from rabbis—either Israeli or international—calling upon the State of Israel to open its borders to incoming Muslim refugees. On the contrary, there have been instances of local rabbis in Israel publicly discouraging their communities from renting housing to African asylum seekers, framing them as "dangerous infiltrators". While some rabbis and human rights groups have issued letters regarding humanitarian treatment or provision of aid to refugees in neighboring areas, these statements stop short of calling for Israel to directly take in large numbers of Muslim refugees as they do in campaigns directed at Western nations.
Thus, your point is supported by the available evidence: the strong, visible rabbinical advocacy for open refugee policies is overwhelmingly directed at Western countries, with little parallel movement to alter Israel's restrictive border and immigration stance regarding Muslim refugees.
Is There a Coherent Immigration Policy in Israel? - ejournals
Prime Minister Netanyahu said at the opening of the Cabinet Meeting of 3 January 2018: Every state must maintain its borders, and protecting the borders from ...
https://ejournals.eu/pliki_artykulu_czasopisma/pelny_tekst/0fd0fd9f-58bc-475e-aba7-49c6c14574b9/pobierz
Muslim Africans' Harrowing Journey to Israel - Middle East Forum
"I was dancing with joy when I arrived. It was one of the happiest days of my life." So spoke Ismail Abdul-Rasul, a father of four from Darfur in Sudan, describing his 2007 ...
https://www.meforum.org/middle-east-quarterly/muslim-africans-harrowing-journey-to-israel
If Israel accepted Syrian refugees and IDPs in the Golan Heights
As the conflict in Syria enters its fourth year, Israel remains Syria's only neighbour which has still not accepted displaced persons and refugees fleeing the armed ...
https://www.fmreview.org/syria/plotner/
Immigration Policy of Israel: The Unique Perspective of a Jewish State
2015 IMMIGRATION POLICY IN ISRAEL 1097 Jewish immigrants and their relatives and spouses over immigrants from all other groups. The new law specifically singles out...
https://digitalcommons.tourolaw.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2684&context=lawreview
NEW ISSUES IN REFUGEE RESEARCH - UNHCR
12 his municipality. Another example of a religious-ethnonational discourse was the call of local rabbis in South Tel-Aviv's depraved neighbourhoods...
https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/legacy-pdf/4d7a26ba9.pdf





